Category Archives: Gender

Ambedkarite Buddhist Women and their everyday life in India: A study across changing time

January 07, 2025 | By Shubhangi Satkar
Ambedkarite Buddhist Women and their everyday life in India: A study across changing time

I measure the progress of a community by the degree of progress women achieved. Dr.B. R. Ambedkar Women religious life is very difficult as any religion cannot give them the right to live freely. Religion confines women’s life through the traditions and cultural norms, which are mainly  created by men and from the patriarchal perspective. Religious systems tend to foster and promote the power and voices of men at the expense of the women who make up the majority of adherents. When we talk about the Indian context, people of many religions live in India. Every religion has different aspects, ideology and different practices. A majority of Indian people have faith in one or the other religion, they live a religious life in private and public domain. For instance, in the Hindu practices, they wear religious thread on their wrist, they wear ashtgandh (saffron colour) on their forehead and they wear religious clothes also.

Through all this we recognize the religious people. It shows that they carry the religious identity every day. The question of women’s religious life remains controversial because women’s religious life has been controlled by men. In many religions men run the human culture, most aspects of human culture have been run by men, who have often used them to control women. The reason I am talking here about men and religion is that through this paper I am trying to understand the gendered aspect in the religious lives of Ambedkarite Buddhist women. In the contemporary period, women have gained awareness about their rights in every aspect, such as religious, political, social, educational and economical rights. Women have begun making choices about their life, and try to follow the path they have chosen. But many women  still live their life under the control of men, because they are not financially independent.

They  have spent their all life in doing house chores and looking after their family. Therefore, they have not been to live freely. So they have had to be dependent on their husband’s earnings and have also been subjected to the family pressure that women should work in four walls and take care of their children, husband and in-laws. Within this larger context of women’s lived realities in the Indian context, I seek to explore why it is important to understand Ambedkarite Buddhist Women’s life. I argue that the majority of Ambedkarite Buddhist Women are very educated and have become financially independent as s direct consequence of following the Ambedkarite Buddhist ideology.

Their education and financial independence has thus ensured they are not bound by the social constraints that society has historically imposed on women and they are able to achieve a greater degree of freedom in their everyday lives than earlier. I argue that these achievements of the women in my sample are rooted in the fact that Buddhism teaches us to engage with life’s challenges rather than escaping them. Such teachings havem deeply inspired these women. They have therefore also found the path that gives them greater freedom in their everyday lives. As my respondent discussed, the Buddhist Path gives them freedom from all custom-based practices.

They have faith in the path that Dr. B. R Ambedkar showed them through Buddhism. His life inspired them and helping them to find a meaningful life. The Hindu caste system in India has created a system of unequal status by birth to human beings. Therefore, finding the ways to overcome and dismantle such a system became very important for these women to find the intellectual and meaningful life. Conversion of Dr. B. R Ambedkar in Buddhism Dr. Ambedkar was one of the most educated person in India. He acquired advanced degrees in social sciences. And the law from the best universities in the UK and the US. And through this he studied all social aspects in India and has written many books on the inequalities in Indian society and its religious problems.

In his exemplary and pioneering works, he has brought out how deeply Indian society is based on the caste and religion, where there is a high and low status assigned to people and people are discriminated against on the basis of their caste in the society. He himself experienced discrimination while getting education, because he belonged to a lower caste. Untouchability was practiced with certain castes and Ambedkar belonged to one of the caste among them. Therefore, he spent much time and energy to study the religions in India in great depth and finally decided to convert in to Buddhism. He finds that only the Buddhist path would lead better life, because in Buddhist religion all are equal, man is in centre of the Buddhist religions. Therefore, he embraced Buddhism along with half million people and showed the new path to live life.

Dr. Ambedkar was also concerned about women’s lives in India because women could not move freely in the society, were prevented from getting an education, and they had a secondary position in society. Within the patriarchal structures of Indian society women were considered inferior and therefore confined to the domestic domain. Such discriminatory practices placed women’s lives entirely under the control of men. So in independent India Dr. Ambedkar wrote the Hindu Code Bill to legally codify women’s rights in various domain, but most of the educated people of the time, who belonged to the dominant castes, opposed the idea of Hindu Code bill and ultimately it was rejected in the parliament. Buddhism however does not restrict either educational opportunities of women or their religious freedom. Ambedkarite Buddhist Women and their life. For this research paper I have interviewed four Buddhist women.

Their names are as follows. Suvarna More, Sonali Mhaske and Deepali Chavan . Dr. Suvarna More has completed her PhD in Gender Studies from Pune University and now she is working as a research fellow at the same University. Dr. Sonali Maske, lives in Aurangabad. She has completed her PhD in History dept from Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University and now she is working as a guest faculty in the same university. Deepali Chavhan has done her Master’s in Social work, and a one- year Diploma in gender studies. She is now working on women farmers issues with a well known organization. While interviewing Ambedkarite Buddhist women, I could understand that all of them are well educated.

Three of them have completed their PhD. Now they are employed in reputed Indian educational institutions. One has done her masters and doing job in well recognized NGO. All four women whom I interviewed are aware about the gender / human rights. Apart from their jobs, all four of them are associated with social movements and socially engaged with Buddhism. They are recognized within social, academic and political circles as activists who fight for the equality.

When I asked them about which of Buddha’s teachings they follow the most in their daily life, they all answered that they like the Buddha’s teachings like “Att Deep Bhav”, Maitri, Karuna, Anitya (impermanence) the most and they practice these teachings in their daily life.

They also believe in the path that Ambedkar has shown them of liberty, fraternity and equality. All of them have mentioned about this principle in their interviews. None of them believe in the religious ritual, they all reject it. They believe in being rational and carry the identity of being Buddhist. For them, to live as a Buddhist is not to live religiously, but to live in a rational way. Like many Buddhist people do meditation, All are inspired from the Dr. B. R Ambedkar’s life and his work for the society. He encouraged people to be graduates and work in the academic spaces. He also helped lower caste people in getting jobs in the government sectors. He made us aware about the varna system and taught us to fight against such discriminatory practices towards some communities.

Dr. B. R Ambedkar’s philosophy stands for equality, liberty, fraternity and justice which lead to the path of enlightenment. Therefore, many people call themselves as Ambedkarite Buddhist and these four women are among them. Buddha’s teaching and the path shown by him is a framework for the transformation of society. Since people in India have historically been divided into castes, and people look down upon them on the base of caste, caste-based practices are discriminatory. For instance, people from upper caste people practise  untouchability towards lower caste people and we have been fighting against this for long time. Untouchability is still practiced in the society by particular castes. Therefore, Dr. Ambedkar not only fought for the equality but he also changed his religious identity and became a Buddhist because he considered Buddhism an egalitarian religious system.

The women I interviewed are associated with Buddhist Sangh’s. Two of them are associated with Bauddh Sangharsh Samiti. Sonali is associated with university level Phule-Ambedkar study group that studies Buddhism through the lens of Dr. Ambedkar. Through their association with such groups (named above) they all work to spread the Buddhist teachings among people. They lead the people who wants to become Buddhist towards conversion and living a Buddhist life. They organise retreats on the weekends in different areas where they teach the path of Ambedkar and Buddhism. In this way they meet number of people across the regions and bring them into the group where they can read and understand Buddha’s teachings and can gradually become Buddhist. Such groups mostly have been formed by the educated Buddhist people.

On account of the education they have acquired and the prestigious jobs they hold in the line with their Ambedkarite Buddhist identity, thier personalities appear strong and inspiring and there fore positively influence people who want to adopt Buddhism. Many educated young  people have adopted the Buddhism, they converted to Buddhism and have officially become Buddhist. They are officially recognised as Buddhist, because they took part in the conversion ceremony which is mainly organised in public domain and entails adopting Buddhism through some rituals.

Those who became Buddhist earlier were Hindu i.e they earlier belonged to a religion entrenched in the caste system. So this is the kind of significant and transformative work that these Ambedkarite Buddhist Women are doing. They provide the material to newcomers for reading and studying Buddhism. Through the reading and observing how the Buddhist people are living their lives, the newcomers are initiated into and become Buddhist.However, it is important to note that often people called themselves as Buddhist, but actually they continued to practice the Hindu religion and believed in God. Ambedkarite Buddhist Women on the other hand have denied the existence of God. Once they become a Ambedkarite Buddhist, they don’t believe in God. They become rational and develop reflective thinking.

They give importance to becoming more Ambedkarite and Buddhist. These four women belong to the lower social strata as per the traditionally imposed norms of Hindu society in India. Lower social strata means that in Hindu religion there is a Chaturvarna system, which has four varna’s, Brahmin, Kshatriy, Vaishya and Shudra which the hindu scriptures defines as follows. Brahmins means priests, Kshatriy means solders, Vaishya means traders, and Shudra means menials. Dr. Ambedkar states that these four varna’s made principle of graded inequality the basis for determining the terms that associated life between classes. Under this four varna system, Shudra is not only placed on the bottom of the gradation, but they are subjected to innumerable ignominies and disabilities so as to prevent them from rising above the condition fixed for them by varna system.

So Dr. Ambedkar studied many religion and their respective philosophies and he found that it was the Buddhist path that met his complex requirements of reason, morality and justice. Buddha’s dharma for Dr. Ambedkar was its emphasis on rational choice. So, he decided to embrace Buddhism which would give him a dignity in the society and the ability to lead a meaningful life outside the varna system. The women I interviewed for this paper also place a high value on being rational. But in India being Buddhist is not valuable for varna system, because for the varna system, caste matters the most. As the caste system is followed in every religion except Buddhism. people in the mainstream still view these women as coming from lower castes and discriminate against them on that basis.

A large number of Hindus live in India and they caste inequality in in graded in their mindset, they continue to see people from the graded caste perspective. In such a society, women were given a secondary position, so we see that women were deprived of their basic rights. Therefore, such women give more importance to becoming an Ambedkarite Buddhist in search of their way of liberation, because becoming a Ambedkarite Buddhist means on the one hand to fight against such caste system and on the other hand to live a conscious and rational life by imbibing the Buddha’s teachings. Being women, we all know how we live our life. These women are happy and feel proud of being Ambedkarite and Buddhist.

All the women I interviewed are the first-generation learners in their families. They said that because of the education they acquired, they were able to study the social issues in the practises of religion. They also said that they could learn to see differences on the basis of class and caste. They said that women who don’t get education are not able to fight against the customs of the society, when you get education you become a competent person, and can fight for your rights. Through it, women find their ways where they find the way to liberation and a meaningful life.

Therefore, Buddhist women in India give more importance to become Ambedkarite Buddhist because Ambedkar embraced Buddhism and showed a new and liberating path in India. They said that being a Buddhist in India is a distinction. As Buddhists we learn two things. One is that being an Ambedkarite Buddhist means we move forward in response to the discrimination that exists under the caste system, and the other is that we as Buddhists follow the Buddha’s path shown by the Dr. Ambedkar, whereby we look at our lives as they are and find a way that empowers us to live. Also, while living a religious life as a Buddhist, they say that many times negativity arises in life, but we make a way out of negativity, the negative feeling in us never ends.

Conclusions – Ambedkarite Buddhist women look to Buddhism as a hopeful way of living in such aprecarious world. They look upon Buddhist path as meaningful and peaceful way. Their identity stands out from other Buddhist women as a strong identity. They live a revolutionary life, trying to make others adopt the same path that they have got through becoming a Buddhist. The change in the lives of these women can be seen due to education. Through education they could understand Buddhism better. They all find the Buddhist teachings very effective which lead their life toward emancipations. Babasaheb Ambedkar’s influence can be seen in their life today, and being an Ambedkarite Buddhist means living a self-respecting life for them.

(Dalit Times)

Condition of Dalit Women in Indian Society

December 24, 2024 | By Akhilesh Kumar
Condition of Dalit Women in Indian Society

Dalit Women doesn’t come under the Varna system, they were known as Untouchables(now popularly known as Dalit),in Constitutional term Dalit women come under the Scheduled Caste(SC).Among women in India Dalit Women is the most oppressed Women in India, Dalit women face triple discrimination on the basis of Caste, on the basis of class and on the basis of Gender. Dalit women has to fight for everythinng for their survival.as a whole Dalit community face discrimination, atrocities but Dalit women face the worst. according to recent data from NCRB(National Crime Record Beauro),there is increase in the crime against the Dalit community, everyday 10 Dalit Women are being raped, this are the case which is recorded, imagine the case which are not recorded.

Dalit has faced humiliatation, discrimination since thousands of years. when Constitution came into existence discrimination, untouchability has been outlawed by the Constitution but even today Dalit face discrimination, humilation, atocities, Untouchability in the society. According to recent census of 2011,Dalit makes 16.6% of the India’s population,and this population of India face discrimination, humilation, atrocities in every part of the Country. Dalit women fought for their rights in the society and they also fought against the Britishers but unfortunately the Savrana community has forgotten their contribution for the society, the women like Jhalkaribai devi, Uda Devi Pasi, Mahabiri devi Bhangi, they all fought against the Britishers and for equality in the society but unfortunately this women has not given importance by the historian, only because they  were Dalit Women.

Dalit women has shown resistence against the brutal Caste system because Dalit Women faced the worst, the Perpetrators think that if you want to humiliate the particular community then humiliate its women. In South the women from Dalit community were not allowed to cover their Breast, they had to give Breast tax,even today the condition of Dalits in South is not well and most particularly in TamilNadu, recently the people from dominant OBC community threw Human Excreta in a tank used by Dalits. Dalit Women faced the worst kind of humiliation, discrimination, atrocities, Untouchability in the society.

When Savarna women started movement for demanding equality in the society, Savarna women claimed themselves as the mainstream Feminism but Savarna Women have neglected the issues of Dalit Women, the experience of Dalit women is different from the Savarna women, Savarna women are not being discriminated on the basis of Caste, Savarna women doesn’t get humiliated on the basis of Caste, they don’t face the brutal form of Caste violence from the society. The experience of Dalit Women is very different from the Savarna Women, the emergence of Dalit feminism has taken place only because Savarna Feminist were not taking the issues of Dalit Women, Dalit Feminism sees everything from the intersectional perspectives. We find many a times the Savarna Women silent on the daily atrocities of Dalit Women.

In this Patriarchal society Dalit Women is the most sufferer. every year there is increase in the crime against Dalit and particularly against Dalit Women.the crime against Dalit women include rape,brutal sexual assault,gangrape,sexual harrasment.Constitution has given Constitutional safeguards to Dalits,but even though Dalits face discrimination,atrocities and Untouchability.the society treat Dalit as worst than animals,to teach Dalit Community lesson,firstly perpetrators do violence against the Dalit Women,they think that if we humiliate the body of a dalit women the Dalit community will be humiliated.everytime whenever Dalit community started to raise voice against the injustice,the people who have Castiest Mindset started to do violence against the dalit community and particularly against Dalit Women,the Castiest Mindset people doesn’t want to see a Dalit in a better position,they don’t want to see Dalit aquiring land,they don’t want to see Dalit studying in good schools and colleges.the Castiest people thinks how a Dalit can stand up against them.

The more Dalits are getting aware about their rights,the more violence are taking place against Dalit and particularly against Dalit Women,the Castiest people thinks how a Dalit who is doing menial work,started to assert the rights as a human beings,so they harras,rape Dalit women to teach dalit community lesson.it is not that only common Dalit women are facing atrocities by the Castiest Mindset people,also Dalit women who are in prominent postition faced the castiest slur from  people mainly from the Savarna community.Kumari Mayawati a tallest leader who comes from Dalit community faced most casteist slur by the people from Savarnas community.when you see in social media,most Casteist slur have been used against Kumari Mayawati only because she is a Dalit women,among all the politicians she is the only women who face Castiest slur,vulgar jockes only because she comes from Dalit community.

In every crime which took place against Dalit community, police also don’t do fair investigation and many a times Judges are also baised against the Dalit community.the case of  Lalasa Devi can be a example,the case of Delta Meghwal,whenever any atrocities happened against Dalit women or Dalit,firstly SC/ST atrocities act invoked and then other charges are invoked,but in cases on the atrocities of  Dalit women,police refused to even register FIR against the perpetrator,forget about registering complain under SC/ST act,also in the Case of Lalasa Devi Police refused to register complain under SC/ST act and even refused to register the charges of rape on the perpetrators.Delta Meghwal was the bright Dalit student who was raped and killed by her teacher,a women was also a perpetrator in this case.

in many atrocities which took place against Dalit Women in that many a times women from upper caste also involved in it.no one can forget the Hathras case,how a Dalit girl brutally raped and killed by the Upper Caste Thakur men,in that police has tried to protect the rapist,the body of girl being burnt by the police in  the midnight,and later they denied that rape has happened,till now justice has not been delivered to the victim’s family,Recently the UP Court acquitted three rapist and only one is behind the bar but not on charges of rape,UP Special Court said that it is not incident of gang rape,out of the four accused three are acquitted from all charges,only one is behind the bar but not on charges of Rape,this is happening only because victim is from Dalit community.where is the outrage by the Savarna feminist,there is no outrage from the Savarna Feminist because the victim is from Dalit community.all the Savarna feminist keep mum,all the Savarna media houses kept mum whenever atrocities took place against Dalit women,Dalit women are the marginalized among marginalized.

Who can forget Khairlanji incident of 2006 of Maharashtra,where Dalit Family was brutalized by Dominant OBC Hindu Community,it was the small  conflict of land and the stature of Dalit Family was not liked by the Castiest people,the Women of the Dalit Family was gang raped by the Castiest goons killed Dalit family in most brutal way,only One person from that Dalit Family survived but he also died without getting Justice for her wife and other family members.there is difference between crime against Savarna Women and Dalit Women,When Dalit Women are killed, Brutalized no voice,no support came from the Savarna Community and the so called Savarna liberal media,but when any crime against Savarnas community happens,whole country get outraged but the consciousness of Society died When Crime against Dalits happen,they will say Black lives Matters but they never say that Dalit lives Matters or Muslim lives Matters.

The caste violence against Dalit is continuing since thousands of years, they were debarred from getting education, they were debarred from enjoying basic rights as a human beings, they were regarded as Untouchable, even today they are regarded as an Untouchables, even today they are regarded as impure. still today they have been killed, lynched, Dalit Women are being violated in most brutal way by the dominant Caste people. why dominant Caste do violence aganist Dalit, most probably because they are fearful of their assertiveness, they are jealous of their prosperity. they think how a Dalit can assert in front of dominant caste. the most brutal Caste violence take place against the Dalit Women, they are being sexually assulted in a brutal way. year by year the crime against Dalit in General and Dalit women in particular are increasing, and in almost all the cases the Justice are being delayed or Justice are being denied to Dalits.

Baba Saheb Ambedkar who was the chief architect of the Indian Constitution has made special provision in the Indian Constitution for the protection of Dalit, but even though Dalit face atrocities everyday. when ever atrocities against Dalits take place there is not much outrage from the people in India, and the celebrities in India, recently in USA when a black man was killed by the white policemen of USA, the Indian celebrities and politician had raised the voice, but when atrocities against Dalit happens in their own home they keep silent or in other words put fevicol in there mouth. there is need that the people should also speak up when atrocities against Dalits took place. if we want to make egalitarian society where every individual enjoy equal rights. than, every individual has to stand up whenever any injustice took place in society and speak up against any injustice.

(Dalit Times)

Rembering Phulan Devi’s cold blooded murder

August 30, 2024 | By Avani Kulshrestha
Rembering Phulan Devi’s cold blooded murder

After the brutal assassination, Umed Singh commented, “People don’t like it when someone from the lower classes a woman rises up and makes a name for herself.” Her lawyer, Kamini Jaiswal, agreed saying, “This killing comes from caste conflict.”

Edit : Sushma Tomar 

Phoolan Devi, born on August 10, 1963 established herself as a feared Indian bandit before stepping into politics and winning a seat in the Parliament. Her story shaped by hardship, revolt, and clout in government, stands out as a gripping tale of standing up to unfairness.

Phoolan Devi came from the Mallaah subcaste and grew up in a small town in Uttar Pradesh. A fight over land left her family worse off, making their life harder. Her parents married her off when she was just eleven, and she became a victim sexual abuse. This incident motivated her to join a gang of bandits. In July 1979, a gang run by Babu Gujjar kidnapped her. She went through repeated attacks until Vikram Mallah, the second-in-charge killed Gujjar and took over. Mallah taught Phoolan how to shoot a rifle, and they grew close. Together, they led their gang to rob villages of higher-caste folks. This earned Phoolan the nickname “Dasyu Sundari” (Beautiful Bandit) and celebrated her as a Robin Hood figure.

Phoolan Devi was later arrested in 1983, when she was accused of carrying out the Behmai massacre, where twenty men were shot dead. This brutal act forced the Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh to step down.

After evading capture for two years, she surrendered to the authorities in 1983 through a negotiated deal. She then spent eleven years in Gwalior prison as she waited for her trial.

Phoolan Devi was released in 1994 after her charges were set aside; she subsequently became a politician and was elected as a member of parliament for the Samajwadi Party in 1996. She lost her seat in 1998 but got it back the next year. She held this position until she died in 2001. During her time in politics, Phoolan fought for women’s rights and better living conditions for the poor. She wanted to bring hospitals, schools, electricity, and clean water to villages.

However, her criminal charges those linked to the Behmai massacre always hung over her. At first, these charges were put aside, but were brought to the surface by the Kanpur District Court. The Allahabad High Court supported this decision. In 1996, the Supreme Court said denied her request to drop the charges, but she could stay free until her trial.

On July 25, 2001, Phoolan Devi was assassinated by Sher Singh Rana killed Phoolan Devi outside her home in New Delhi. Doctors declared her dead at Lohia Hospital after she took nine bullets. Her assassination forced everyone the world over to acknowledge the casteism and unfairness in Indian society.

After the brutal assassination, Umed Singh commented, “People don’t like it when someone from the lower classes a woman rises up and makes a name for herself.” Her lawyer, Kamini Jaiswal, agreed saying, “This killing comes from caste conflict.”

hoolan Devi’s story led to the 1994 film Bandit Queen, which she did not support due to the unpreferable representation of her character. Her life has also inspired several biographies and her dictated autobiography was entitled I, Phoolan Devi. There are varying accounts of her life because she told differing versions to suit her changing circumstances.

People around the world remember her as someone who stood up to injustice. Her memory is kept alive due to public retelling of her life stories and through books and movies. Phoolan Devi’s story lives on, showing how people can fight against unfairness and discrimination.

Social Media fame Shivani Kumari joins Big Boss OTT 3

August 31, 2024 | By Nitya Kaimal
Social Media fame Shivani Kumari joins Big Boss OTT 3

An influencer from a village in UP joins the latest season Big Boss OTT. With a large following on both Instagram and YouTube, Shivani Kumari adds diversity and more representation to the reality show.

Big Boss OTT 3 recently announced members of its new cast, with Shivani Kumari being one of the additions. Fans are buzzing with curiosity, and while not much information is available about this rural influencer, here is what we do know about her.

Shivani Kumari is a 22-year-old influencer from the Aryari village in Uttar Pradesh. Starting her social media journey on TikTok in 2019, Shivani blew up with her unique content, sharing videos of her daily life in rural India with her mother and siblings. After the app’s ban, she shifted to YouTube, where she has amassed a massive following. Additionally, she has starred in several music videos such as ‘Shor’ and ‘Balma’ among others, Most of her videos include snippets of her family and their life in Aryari, along with the usual lip-syncing and fashion videos that dominate social media.

Fans and supporters are drawn to her happy-go-lucky and magnetic energy that is visible in all her videos, and she creates the perfect mix of following trends while maintaining her distinctive charm, without compromising her rural background and life. The authenticity of her content, including videos of her helping around the house, feeding animals, interacting with her family, and all in her local dialect adds to her appeal. Fans believe that she will be an excellent addition to the cast of Big Boss, and are proud of how she will represent rural India on such a large platform.

Her mother is an agricultural labourer, supporting the family after her father’s demise, which is known through the memorable tributes Shivani posts on her Instagram. Shivani is also seen posting pictures with posters and statues of Ambedkar, which has led to speculation about her caste identity. While this information is not verified, some sources online say that her family belongs to the Kushwaha caste, an OBC community predominant in UP.

In her early days in a video with YouTuber Anjul Bamhrolia, she asked him “Bhaiya humko kaun dekhega? Hum toh gaun ke hai?” to which he replied confidently saying “Tum Saurabh Joshi se bhi aage jaogi kyunki tumhare paas asli kahaani hai”. She now has over 2 million subscribers on YouTube and had 4 million followers on her previous Instagram account.

Shivani is set to star in Big Boss OTT 3 alongside the viral ‘Vada Pav Girl’ Chandrika Dixit. Fans have also taken to social media to call for ‘Dolly Chaiwala’ as a contestant as well. Dolly Chaiwala is famous for documenting his travels across the globe as he shares his tea with locals and public figures, including Bill Gates, which blew up his social media account. He is also a Dalit and a vocal Ambedkarite.

Women and film industry

August 30, 2024 | By V K Cherian
Women and film industry

The gender question in films becomes a serious issue in Kerala threatening to spread to other parts of India.

From Thiruvananthapuram in Southern tip of the country to Kolkata in Eastern part the ripples of the Justice Hema Committee report on gender issues in Malayalam films are being felt. With Bengali actor, Sreelekha Mitra, accusing the Kerala Chalachitra Academy Chairman and Malayalam film director Ranjit  of inappropriate behavior resulting in his resignation, what began as  a storm in Malayalam film tea cup threaten to blast across States. There are already demands of similar study in other State cinemas filed to examine the gender issues.

The Kerala government appointed Justice Hema , senior actress Sharda and  retired women  IAS officer to enquire into gender issues in Malayalam films, following the infamous  molestation case of an actress in a car, alleged planned by an actor. Following the public outcry, the government under press pressure from Women in Cinema Collective, a group of film professionals, appointed the committee. The report was submitted in 2019, but kept under wraps, following the sensitive nature of the contents.

However following activists approaching courts to get it publicized the Kerala High Court allowed its publication, minus the names mentioned in the report and has rightly opened up a Pandora’s Box of atrocities on women working in the film field. But no one thought there will be an allegation of a “casting Couch” effort by Chalachitra Academy Chairman himself, by a leading lady of Bengal cinema. Many junior artists and have opened alleged their bad experiences and put the Association of Malayalam Artists (AMMA) a powerful body of film actors under the mat. Though they pleaded innocence, one lady artist has implicated its ex- Secretary and difference of opinion on the response from senior members has come into light. Going by the media report, it is worst season for predators in cinema filed, worst than what they faced during the “me “too, season.

Kerala government has planned a conclave of all stakeholders to find a way out the situation. But there is call for strict action against those perpetrators who are being named by the survivors, including that of the Chalachitra Academy Chairman. For Malayalam films it is period of internal strife. For sure the routine predators in the film sets will have a difficult time as the government agencies and social groups have put their surveillance on the film sets, which is being identified as the main play ground of gender offenders.

High lights from the Report:

Findings:

“Sexual demands made to women for the very entry into cinema and getting chance to work in the cinema. Sexual harassment abuse, assault again women, at workplace, transportation, place of accommodation etc.. Torture of women if they express their resentment or   unwillingness on sexual demands. Violation of human rights of women in cinema by not providing basic facilities like toilets  and changing room on the sets. Lack of safety, security   in cinema, in accommodation, transportation etc.  Unauthorized and illegal banning of individuals working in cinema in different  categories Silencing of women under threat of ban from work in cinema. Male domination in the industry, gender bias, gender discrimination. Gross indiscipline in cinema  –consumption of alcohol &, use of drugs, disorderly conduct / misbehavior at work place. Making of demeaning and vulgar comments at workplace, over phone etc. Non-execution of contract in writing between employers and employees, to suit individual requirements. Failure. to pay even consented remuneration. Disparity of remuneration between man and woman and gender discrimination In remuneration. Resistance/reluctance to allow women into cinema especially on technical side and lack of opportunity Online harassment (cyber-attack). Lack or legal awareness of women about their own rights. Absence of any legally constituted authority to redress the grievances.

The report went on to observe that :”From the evidence adduced before the Committee, we find that women are denied even basic human rights in Malayalam film industry, by not providing adequate facilities like toilets and changing rooms, on shooting locations. Almost all the women who were examined before the Committee stated that there is no toilet facility or changing room on the set, especially while shooting is done in many outdoor locations, which will be in remote places.

During menstrual periods, the women in cinema face a being in a position to use water or other facility even to change or dispose of sanitary napkins, it is pointed out. It is also stated before us that woman in cinema or forced to hold back urge for urination for a very long time.

This was also brought to the notice of many members of AMMA. Discussion was also held at the meeting of AMMA relating to toilet problems. They expected AMMA to take necessary action to make available toilets, through the producers’ association. But nothing was done so far, and human rights violation continues.

We are convinced that women suffer considerably, mentally and physically due to non-availability of toilets and changing rooms on the set.

“Compromise” and “adjustment” are two terms which are very familiar among women in Malayalam film industry and the by, they are asked to make herself available for sex on demand.

Many women in cinema stated before us that after WCC was formed, they found a forum where they could safely disclose instances of sexual harassment which they have gone through. Till then, they were all keeping to themselves, all their experiences and suffering the brunt that they have gone through, not being able to disclose it even to family members since their parents were reluctant to send them to cinema because of the bad name for the film industry.

Another witness stated before the committee that there may also women who would be willing to adjust to the demands and she herself has seen certain mothers who are conniving at the situation and believe that there is nothing wrong in it

Some of the witnesses also produced certain video clips, audio clips, screenshots of WhatsApp messages etc., to establish the fact that there is demand for sex for the very entry into cinema and that certain people in the industry persuade them to make themselves available for sex.

If a person thinks that a woman is a problem-maker, she will not be called to the cinema again. Therefore, women who are passionate of acting will be suffering all the atrocities, silently. To a question put by the Committee to this witness whether other women in cinema had same experience, she said may be they have, but they are scared to state their problems openly.

It is brought to the notice or the committee that a prominent actor in Malayalam cinema referred to the powerful lobby which exists in film industry as “mafia” in cinema, since they could do anything in cinema, according to their whims and fancies and even ban very prominent directors, producers, actors or any other person even though such ban is illegal and unauthorized.

We have absolutely no hesitation to state that there must be an independent forum which must be constituted by the government1 as per a statute, to deal with the problems of Women  in cinema.

As per evidence adduced before the committee, both oral and documentary, certain actors in cinema (some of them are also producers, distributors, exhibitor or directors) — all male– gained enormous fame and wealth and they are in full control the whole Malayalam ‘film” industry now. Many men in the industry stated before us emphatically that many individuals were banned from cinema that includes even famous actors.

According to members of WCC that many men have openly stated to them that the members of WCC will not be allowed to work in cinema. None dares to take the members of WCC in Cinema since they openly spoke about various things which are not to the liking of many in the industry. Instead of taking members of WCC in a movie, they go for other women who are available. Certain Other Producers are scared to take members of WCC, since they believe that by choosing them, they would be offending powerful film actors of AM MA.

The Hema committee report also came down heavily on the unions in film industry and their arbitrary involvements in filmmaking.

It is the policy of the union not to allow any person who is not a member of the union to work in any movie, without the identity card issued from the union. This is clearly illegal. The reason for denying membership to make-up artist is that she is a woman

On considering the statements given by various individuals in cinema, both men and women, all the documents which are produced by witnesses and procured by the committee from various sources and having understood during the study, the nature of the working atmosphere of women in film industry, and also how the Malayalam film  industry runs In the present scenario, I have no hesitation to hold that the only solution to the various issues faced by women in cinema to enact a Tribunal  under the government.

The committee recommended a “Constitution of a Tribunal or Appointing a retired District Judge as the Tribunal, preferably a woman, who has a minimum of five years experience on the trial side. The decision of the tribunal shall be final, subject only to a revision before a Division Bench of the High Court.  The powers of the Tribunal include taking assistance of his/her satisfaction a counselor, any expert to mediator, doctor, psychologist/ psychiatrist  lawyer or any other person whether from within the industry or outside the industry can be availed of, as the Tribunal may think it fit and proper1 depending on the facts and circumstances of each dispute.”

This is how Women of Bhima Ka Kheda village zeroed market dependency

July 11, 2024 | By Vaagdhara
This is how Women of Bhima Ka Kheda village zeroed market dependency

There is a famous saying by Roy T. Bennett “Dedicate yourself to what gives your life true meaning and purpose; make a positive difference in someone’s life.”, these lines correlate with 20 women residing in Bhima Ka Kheda in Ghatol Tehsil, Banswara. These women have not only changed their lives but also connected with other women of their village to change their lives as well.

Most of these women have been practicing farming for ages, but little did they know the nuances of farming that would improve resources and livelihood at the same time, it was after connecting with a programme named SIFS (Sustainable Integrated Farming System) implemented by Vaagdhara with the support of KKS Germany, that they have started practicing integrated farming that helped enhance their income and improve their livelihood.

One of the women farmers of ‘Saksham Samuh’, Paru Devi proudly says, “I was so ignorant earlier that when someone approached me and asked me regarding farming and livelihood, I would keep mum but now after sufficient training and capacity building through SIFS programme, I have managed to learn a lot of things which has boosted my confidence. I am associated with this programme since 2009, every month a group of 20 women meets to discuss and share new techniques and resources.” She adds, under the SIFS programme timely training and capacity building are done that helps improve food security and enhance income.

Giving an example of enhanced livelihood, Devi shared after acquiring knowledge of animal husbandry, she decided to get goats of the Sirohi breed, and currently, she has five of them, and she is getting 10 liters of milk daily, this is enough to fulfill her family needs and her dependency on market has zeroed down. Besides, she shared that she is a proud owner of a nutrition garden, which she developed by the 10-12 varieties of seeds provided by Banswara-based Vaagdhara civil society. After nurturing and taking care of the soil and seeds, now she has grown vegetables of her choice, and at least five varieties of fruits such as papaya, mulberry, mango, guava, and lemon, again she has managed to zero the dependency on the market, making her family self reliant.

So, Devi’s story is the biggest example of how SIFS techniques have started helping families to ensure their nutrition needs and at the same time reduce their dependence on the market.

A Family and Girl Child Fight With the Malnutrition

July 11, 2024 | By Vaagdhara
A Family and Girl Child Fight With the Malnutrition

Dhula damor and his wife Surta Damor use to live in village Sheranagle, Anandpuri block. They are four members in including two girls child. They have small piece of land i.e. 2 bigha for doing agriculture which is totally rainfed. They use to grow maize, wheat, rice and pigeon pea in cropping season. Poor health of land was a reason for less production and it was available for 5 to 6 months. He used to buy food material to fulfillment of food availability over the year for his family. For this, he migrated to Ahemdabad and Surat where he engages in construction work for 5 months. His wife is stayed at home for taking care of children. During his migration, his wife had suffered for lacking of money. Sometime, in such situation she could not feed her children and she used to sleep starving. Neither she go to Aanganwadi centre and nor sends her children.

A Family and Girl Child Fight With the Malnutrition

One day she took participation in PLA_LANN meeting conducted by VAAGDHARA in her village. In that meeting facilitator was taking anthropometric measurement of participated children (upto 59 months). Kavita whose age was 18 months also measured during the activity and her mother was called and told that your child measure as SAM-Sever Acute Malnourished (Height=70 cm, Weight= 6.3 Kg, MUAC= 10.7 and Z score=-3SD). When she was asked about poor health of the child she replied that the child is weak from birth. In that village LANN volunteer understood her about the situation of the child. Next day Surta took the child to MTC- Malnutrition Treatment Centre which is 73 Kms away from the village. Surta stayed there for 15 days. LANN-Volunteer gave his full support to family in that situation. Dhula came back at home and her wife told everything to him. In next meeting, dhula and his wife come together. After that they attended meeting regularly. 15 days Nutrition camp organized in the village. Surta and her daughter Kavita participated in the camp regularly through which the child’s health improved. After 8 months, she was 26 months old and Height= 76.4 cm, Weight= 8.7 Kg, MUAC= 14 and  Z score= -1SD.

PLA LANN meetings brought changes in their life. Dhula did changes in agriculture. He adopted sustainable Integrated Farming System through and crop diversity increased, saving started after using organic manure and pesticides, started preservation of indigenous seeds for next crop. In summers, they started having dried vegetables including green leafy and others. Family developed Kitchen garden at backyard of home and growing seasonal vegetables and Banana, Mango, Lemon and Papaya fruit plants for their own consumption. Individual diet diversity increased of every member and hunger period is reduced for 3 months. He benefited by MGNREGA and sanctioned individual work plan up to 3 lac amount for his land development work, plantation and compost pit development. Migration is also stopped because he got employment under MGNREGA.

Dalit woman from Rajasthan’s Bharatpur set to be one of the youngest MPs in Lok Sabha

June 15, 2024 | By Madhavi
Dalit woman from Rajasthan’s Bharatpur set to be one of the youngest MPs in Lok Sabha

Sanjana Jatav, 26, from the Congress party, has defeated her BJP rival in the stronghold of Rajasthan Chief Minister Bhajanlal Sharma.

On June 4, as the Lok Sabha poll results were announced, a video of 26-year-old Sanjana Jatav celebrating her victory by dancing to a Rajasthani song went viral on social media. Sanjana, wearing a saree, is set to become one of the youngest members of Parliament in the 18th Lok Sabha.

Sanjana Jatav, a Congress MP-elect from Bharatpur, Rajasthan, comes from a Dalit community. She defeated BJP’s Ramswaroop Koli by 51,983 votes. Despite having no political background or experience, Sanjana decided to run for office, surprising her family who had never dreamed of participating in elections.

“My husband’s grandfather was a sarpanch, but no one in the family ever contested an election above the panchayat level,” Ms. Jatav told The Hindu. She expressed her determination to work for the people. Sanjana Jatav, the wife of a police constable and mother of two, not only defeated Mr. Koli but also won in the stronghold of Rajasthan Chief Minister Bhajanlal Sharma, whose hometown is Bharatpur.

Ms. Jatav believes that the people of Rajasthan voted for her because “too much religion-related violence has made people choose her. Bharatpur witnessed the murder of two Muslim men, Junaid and Nasir, by cow vigilante groups in 2023.

“I am thankful to the party leadership for giving me this opportunity and the people of Bharatpur for their immense love and support,” said Ms. Jatav. The Congress had good reason to trust her. In the 2023 Rajasthan Assembly polls, Ms. Jatav contested from Alwar’s Kathumar and narrowly lost to BJP’s Ramesh Khinchi by just 409 votes.

“The party saw my hard work, which is why the Central leadership trusted me again,” said Ms. Jatav, who is currently a district council member in Rajasthan.

(Dalit Times)

Study of Dalit gender representation in Jogva and Natarang cinema

March 06, 2024 | By Bhagyashree Jawale
Study of Dalit gender representation in Jogva and Natarang cinema

In social science for Research purpose cinema is used as a text to study society. Cinema can be used as history for study the social history. In this research paper I am using Marathi cinema as a text for study the social hierarchies in society. I have selected JOGVA & NATARANG for my research paper. In both the films main characters are drawn from lower caste. Who is deprived caste of our society. In society, caste is based on hierarchy. Where upper caste is proud and powerful against lower caste is who are poor and weak. This reflects in daily practices of life. It includes social practices, cultural practices, ritual practices and traditions of our life. In both of these cinemas cultural practice related to sexual abuse. In Natarang, Tamasha which is popular folk form in Maharashtrian culture has been used. In Tamasha dancers are essentially from lower caste women and men, who entertain (mainly) upper caste men by performing dance. Jogva shows cultural practice in society. Jogva depict a person who has given some duties to do usually Jogata refers to a man and Jogatin refers to a woman. They are forced by society to give up everything and serve the god. Jogata has to give up his male character and act as a woman and for Jogatin marriage is not allowed. This tradition is still followed in some part of rural India in different forms. With the help of these movies, I will try to understand in this research paper how Dalit and gender representation would have demonstrated by social hierarchy.

Research paper

In Indian society there are many hierarchies which are based on different aspects. I have studied two Marathi language films for this research paper. One is Natarang and another film is Jogva. Both films are of different contents but they greatly relate to Indian social hierarchies. In the film Natarang, the struggle of Nachya’s life has been depicted and, in the movie, Jogva, the struggle of the Jogata-Jogatin life has been depicted. The relations between the people are not only based on caste and class, etc. but are also influenced by gender relations. In my research paper I am using Gender and Dalit as categories of analysis of the social hierarchies in Indian society. This is the main concept to understand how the social hierarchies are being maintained in our society. For this research paper, I will start with the concept of Gender. Many scholars have already written on it. For this paper I am referring to Ann Oakley who was among the first few feminist scholars to use this concept says that, “Gender is a matter of culture, it refers to the social classification of men and women into masculine and feminine that people are male or female can usually be judged by referring to biological evidence. That they are masculine or feminine cannot be judged in the same ways: the criteria are cultural, differing with time and place. The constancy of sex must be admitted, but so also must the variability of gender.” She concludes that gender has no biological origin, that the connections between sex and gender are not really natural at all. Gender relations are gender – based relations between women and men, women and women, men and men. Because of patriarchal ideology and system, gender relations everywhere are unequal and hierarchical. Women are subordinated and discriminated against.

My second important concept for this paper is Dalit. Dalit is a socio-political concept, which has many dimensions to its understanding. Researcher Lovedeep Kumar observes that Dalits are the lower parts of our society. It appears that the major stratification in terms of caste was originally based on occupational division without a vertical social hierarchy. Shudras were considered clearly inferior to the other three castes and were constrained to perform only menial jobs. Those doing menial jobs obviously had low status. A person who had a low status in the caste hierarchy also had low status in other hierarchies of the society such as economic or political. Thus for centuries Dalits have been positioned at the bottom of the rigid Indian caste society. People from other castes, who considered themselves to be higher, believe that Dalits are impure by birth and that their touch or sheer presence could be polluting hence, they are assumed to be untouchable. For centuries, Dalits were excluded from the mainstream society and were only allowed to pursue menial occupations like cleaning dry latrines, sweeping, tanning or working as landless labour for meagre daily wages. Almost in whole of the ancient period, they were the people who cultivated the land, mended the shoes, washed the clothes, made the ropes, cleaned the streets and did all types of menial works. Dalits are not only engaged in menial work but are also involved in social and cultural practices which are considered inferior in social status and have social stigma.

Kamla Bhasin says that patriarchy is a social and ideological system which considers men to be superior to women, one in which men have more control over resources and decision making. Patriarchy is historically constructed and its form, content and extent can be different in different contexts, and at different times. Like all societal systems, patriarchy too has an ideology and structure which together ensure that men are heads of households, inheritors of family name and property. All social institutions moreover, are male dominated. Religions have played an important role in creating and perpetuating patriarchal ideology. They have spread notions of male superiority through stories like, Eve was created from Adam’s rib or man is created in the image of God, etc. Today, media and even educational institutions spread patriarchal ideology by showing men to be stronger in decision making positions and women as consumers, dependent and jealous. Ideology plays an important role in perpetuating social systems and controlling people’s minds. For example, by reducing women to bodies and objectifying them, media encourages violence against women. Ideology provides the justification for social behaviour and socio-economic structures. Normally Women’s productive or labour power, Women’s reproduction, Women’s sexuality, Women’s mobility, Property and other economic resources and Social cultural and political institutions are areas of women’s lives and societies can be said to be under patriarchal control.

I am beginning my writing on films with Jogva. Jogva is a Marathi film directed by Rajeev Patil. The film Jogva is based on two books by Dr.Rajan Gavas and one book by Charuta Sagar. Dr.Rajan Gavas’s books are Chaundak and Bhandarayog. Charuta Sagar’s book is Darshan. According to the Jogata tradition the film shows the struggles of Jogata–Jogatin .This film was released in 2009. Upendra Limaye and Mukta Burve have played the lead roles in this movie. Jogata tradition of Southera Maharashtra and Northera Karnataka is shown in this film. In the name of Jogata tradition the Jogata– Jogatin have to face many problems and a lot of harassment from the society. Due to poverty and superstitious mentality, parents turn their children into Jogata-Jogatin under the Jogata tradition. Jogva is asking for alms (begging) in the name of god and Jogva is the traditional right of Jogata -Jogatin. As per the oath taken before the Goddess, both must maintain themselves by begging only. They go from door to door and say, “Akkandi Jogva” meaning “continuous begging”.

In the film Suli and Tayappa are forced to become Jogata-Jogatin. As per the tradition of Jogata Suli should not marry any person in her life and Tayappa being a man, has to stay like a woman. They both meet in a fair of Jogata-Jogatin. They both struggle in their life as they have to face many problems. As Tayappa has to live the life of a Jogata, Suli didn’t recognise his love for her. Tayappa’s love for suli is shown as a proof of his masculinity in the film. Throughout the film he drapes a saree but inside he is a man. In her attempt to break away from this Jogata tradition Suli gets cheated. Afterwards Suli realises the love of Tayappa for her. They both fight against this tradition to get out of their rigid structure and for this Tayappa unties her much entangled Jat (bunch of hair which is stuck together). Jat is said to be a god gifted to the Jogatins to identify them. Tayappa and Suli succeed in getting out of this Jogata tradition. People belonging to the Jogata tradition usually are from poor families and are generally superstitious with reference to their gods. The film Jogva depicts the reality of the Jogatins.

who are cheated and exploited by the male members of society. Both lead characters try to break away from this tradition and the restricted life it imposes on women. These women are easily available and accessible for exploitation by everyone/ every male in society. This is just a glimpse of the unjust, unequal gender relations prevailing in our Indian society. These women are Dalit who have the lowest caste status in the society. They are forced into these cultural activities, which are entertaining the male members of society. There are no upper caste women in this Jogatin tradition who sacrifice themselves for their god. This system provides an easy way upper caste and lower caste males for their sexual fulfilment. As we can observe in society all men and women relations are based on power. This structure provides power and status to men. Upper caste men have the power on both men and women of lower castes but also have power over their caste women The film Jogva shows the male character of Jogatas an existing way of providing sexual fulfilment for other male members of society. Another character in the film, Yamanya tells Tayappa that he cannot survive without men and drink in his life.

In the second film Natarang, the life of Nachya and his struggle is portrayed. The movie is based on Tamasha, a folk form of Maharashtra culture. Natarang is a Marathi film directed by Ravi Jadhav. This film is based on Anand Yadav’s novel „Natarang‟. In Natarang, a farm labourer decides to start a Tamasha troupe. Pandoba is their mentor. He tells other members in the troupe that without a lady dancer tamasha troupe will not succeed. After many difficulties and many problems they find a lady dancer (Naina) for their tamasha performance. But Naina put forth her condition for participation in the tamasha troupe a Nachya. As Nachya is the person who creates comedy on stage, Guna agrees to be a Nachya in the Tamasha .The family member of Guna was obviously not happy with him being a Nachya. The people of the village harass Guna’s family members for playing role of Nachya .They raise questions of Guna’s masculinity. Guna does not care about this issue. He is just happy with the income and success of his troupe. Naina and Guna fall in Love. But Naina does not agree to marry with Nachya. Being a Nachya’s wife she feels insecure in the society. This answer is shocking for Guna .This tamasha troupe is successful in their work. But this tamasha troupe ends with a terrible and horrible end because of the struggle between two political parties. Guna and the women in the troupe are raped by other political party members (men). In our society women are raped for settling scores with the opposite party, community or the enemy. Here Nachya is raped because he does not fit into the identity of a man. He acts like a woman in the tamasha troupe. Nachya is a comic character in performance and in the troupe. It is expected that he should listen to everyone and entertain people. But in the film Guna tries to achieve success without caring for political relations and struggles. Guna behaves like Nachya‟ only in the performance. But otherwise he exerts his identity as a man and refuses to lives like a woman and entertain male members of society.
In both films Natarang and Jogva the contents different but throw a light on the Indian Social hierarchies. They describe the hierarchies based on Gender, Dalit and Patriarchy. In both, films Tayappa and Guna dress like women. This does not show their masculinity. In the patriarchal structure there are fixed rules and regulations about how women and men should dress up. But the Indian context our social hierarchies have stated which men have the right to show their masculinity in society. With these hierarchies upper caste men always have power on lower caste men and women. This hierarchy is a part of patriarchy, where men have different power relations with each other. Both customs are shining examples of social injustice and exploitation of Dalits. In society patriarchy has accepted only two possibilities of gender, men and women. Other /third gender is not accepted as a part of society. Tayappa and Nachya represent men in the third gender who are actually men but do take up the life of being a female or exhibiting feminine traits. And they are easily accessible to upper caste men in society. This shows the power relations between different strata of society.

Conclusion

Society looks upon the tradition of Jogva as something reserved exclusively for illiterate and backward people belonging to the lower strata of society. This tradition is not looked down upon by others in society. In Natarang the Tamasha is folk form of Maharashtrian culture. It is accepted by society as a part of culture which entertains. If we observe the traditions shown in both the films, they are related to lower caste customs. In patriarchy men and women relations are not equal and are essentially power relations in society the caste decides who are in what position. Dalits are not only engaged with menial work but also work which is considered as a jobs with low value and status. Dalits are engaged in cultural practices, which have a lower status and also carry a stigma. As mentioned by many scholars, Dalit is not relating to only Buddhists and Mahars but also who are politically, socially and culturally backward. Both practices are different from each other but the main content of practices is that Dalits suffered from social injustices and were still are exploited. As Dalits are on the lowest rung of the social ladder they were denied entry into several occupations which were relatively cleaner. They were associated with a variety of specialized traditional occupations such as scavenging, cobbling and disposal of carcasses etc.

During one of the performance, Guna tries to play the role of Arjun. But the audience does not approve of Guna in the role of Arjun. They expect him to play „Nachya‟ only. And to show their disapproval they stone the artists on stage. So Guna’s dream of performing other roles in his career is shattered. In Natarang as mentioned earlier, Guna is raped because he is performing Nachya’s character in the Tamasha. Guna does not accept the identity of being a “women‟ when he is not performing on stage. But the society looks upon him only as “Nachya‟. So when he tries to fight back a group of men and exert him identity as a man, it is not tolerated by other men. So in order to teach him a lesson, he is raped. In Jogva, Tayappa did not like this Jogata tradition. At every step of his life he fought against being a Jogata. Men in society tried to sex with Tayappa. At this point Tayappa is shown to expresses with all his might that, “he is a man‟.

In both films Tayappa as Jogata and Guna as Nachya are victims social injustices and sexual exploitations because they have social status as Dalits and have third gender identity. Both identities have social stigma in society. For centuries Dalits have been positioned at the bottom of the rigid Indian caste system. People from other castes, who consider themselves to be higher, believe that Dalits are impure by birth and that their touch or sheer presence could be polluting hence, they are assumed to be untouchable. Gender is a matter of culture. It refers to the social classification of men and women into masculine‟ and feminine‟. People are identified as males and females and can usually be judged by referring to the biological evidence. But being a third gender is not easily accepted by our rigid society. Both Nachya and Tayappa are suffer because they challenge the norms and regulations are prescribed by society which are gender norms, patriarchal structures and being Dalit in society.

Jai Khamkar, a woman who lost her eyes forever, but changed the thinking of the society with her perspective

March 06, 2024 | By Maati Maajra
Jai Khamkar, a woman who lost her eyes forever, but changed the thinking of the society with her perspective
from Dalit Times

“I may not be able to see but I do not consider myself blind, I cannot see but I also have a point of view. Sight and viewpoint are two different things. My point of view and my mission is the same, to make disabled people self-reliant”
– Jai Khamkar

“Jai Khamkar”,  a woman belonging to a farmer family, almost lost her life at the age of 17. Even the doctor had said that “this girl will not survive” but this girl fought against death for 6 months and defeated death. But this girl lost her eyes forever. It was only after losing his eyes that he recognized the real light of life and with this light illuminated the lives of disabled and visually impaired people.

Jai Khamkar’s year 1997

Jai Khamkar’s life was full of difficulties. He faced a lot of struggles in his life. According to BBC report, in the year 1997, Jai Khamkar was studying in 12th class. She had fever at that time, so a doctor in a private hospital gave her an injection, after which she became unconscious. When he regained consciousness, there was a reaction on his body. The face, eyes, hands and feet were swollen. “His family members started feeling that he was being possessed by someone.” Demon. Finally, after four days, he was sent to the Thane government office. Admitted to hospital.” When he was admitted to the hospital, the situation had become very bad. The skin of the body had peeled off and the body was becoming weak. She wanted to scream in pain. Talking about her condition, Jai Khamkar says, “After examination, the doctor said that the reaction occurred due to the expiry date of the injection.”

The doctor said that now she will not survive

During that time, Jai Khamkar’s condition was so bad that the doctors had told her that she would not survive. Then her treatment started and she stayed in the hospital for a few months after which her vision started getting blurred as she struggled with wounds, painkillers, saline, injections. According to the BBC report, Jai Khamkar said, “It must have been 4 months, my vision stopped. During that illness my eyes could not read. After six months I came home from the hospital.” Jai Khamkar had completely lost her vision and she was unable to accept it. But gradually Jai Khamkar accepted this truth.

Opportunity to run a telephone booth

Overcoming all the problems of life, Jai Khamkar had also completed his studies. He got the opportunity to run an STD telephone booth at a short distance from the village. Talking to BBC on this, Jai Khamkar says, “People were surprised that despite being blind, I can answer the phone so many times. I became so good at it that I memorized about 1,000 phone numbers. People were also surprised.”

Establishment of Malganga Blind Disabled Service Society

Due to his success at the telephone booth, many disabled and visually impaired people started asking Jai Khamkar for help. Jai Khamkar helped hundreds of disabled and visually impaired people in the villages of Pune get certificates. Then Jai Khamkar established Malganga Andha-Apan Seva Sanstha in 2005 to make disabled and visually impaired people self-reliant. Earlier, for self-employment, Jai Khamkar had started the business of making onion and potato bags.

Faced with taunts from people

This journey was not easy for Jai Khamkar, he had faced many ups and downs in his personal life. He also had to face harsh words from his relatives. His relatives or people used to say to him that you are blind, what do you want to do?

Even in the matter of marriage, he was asked sharp questions but he was married to a relative. According to BBC report, even when Jai Khamkar was working at a telephone booth, people used to taunt her and say that you are blind, what will you do ?

Professional help to 52 visually impaired girls and disabled people

Malganga Sanstha had started working to make the blind and disabled self-reliant. When the organization started working in 2014, some disabled and visually impaired girls from Pune came in contact with them. An advertisement had attracted the attention of these girls. It was written on this advertisement that “Professional help to 52 visually impaired girls and disabled people”. When Jai Khamkar talked to these girls, he came to know that the hostel where they used to stay and study in different colleges has now been closed. They have no option but to earn. When Jai Khamkar was working on issues related to students with disabilities, she started New Vision Art and Commerce College in 2019. Students from all over Maharashtra and also from outside states used to come to study in this college.

Establishment of education and hostel at one place

Now the biggest question was that without a hostel, where were they all going to stay? Therefore, all of them left their studies and went to their respective villages. According to BBC report, while talking about this, Jai Khamkar says, “At that time I felt very sad that we could not do anything for them in a place like Pune. So I decided that one day we will set up education and hostels for these girls at one place.” After this, Jai Khamkar sent the proposal to the Education Department but he did not get much success in it.

But after repeatedly contacting the government, his college got approval in 2017. Talking to BBC on this, Jai Khamkar says that this is the first such college for the blind and disabled. He had demanded grants from the central and state governments. In which permission was also given to schools of class XI-XII. He said that college and hostel should be together.

Jai Khamkar, Image Credit BBC